GVR4592
20+ Year Contributor
- 4,300
- 73
- Oct 2, 2004
-
Bellingham,
Washington
TSIfreek said:I would not use the cometic. Use the stock head gasket with the studs and will be more than you need. You will not benefet using the steel head gasket unless your boosting over 30 psi and cometics are even prone to leaking then. Guys run 28 psi on stock head gaskets all the time with out problems. Steel HGs are way over rated and cause more problems than good.
That is completely untrue. Almost every issue with any MLS headgasket failure is improper installation or bad tuning. I agree that it's unneeded for most cars, but it will outperform the stock gasket when it is installed correctly and it will not leak. Plenty of people run 40+ psi on Cometic gaskets without any issues.
I bet 90% of the people on this site that have a MLS gasket don't know what the surface finish in RA is on their head or block. That is where the problem lies. Another 9% think anything under 10 counts of knock is ok and they know nothing about how the stock knock detection system works. The last 1% have no problems with their gaskets, because they know what RA is and they know that any detonation is bad news for a headgasket, especially at higher boost levels. Detonation causes a huge pressure spike in the cylinder, when you add 30+ psi to that it compounds the spike tremendously and destroys the gasket. No gasket will stand up to extended periods of detonation, and most people don't monitor it closely enough to know when they have detonation.
I've never blown a head gasket, I've never had one leak, or push coolant. I've boosted over what my 30 psi gauge can read, I know the RA on my head and block is much lower than it needs to be. I know that any detonation will kill a head gasket, especially at higher boost levels. I know that in the instructions it says not to use copper spray, but almost half of the people that use MLS gaskets spray them anyway. I've never seen a gasket just fail due to manufacturing or design defects, it's always been user error.
I've boosted the stock gasket and bolts to 28 psi, and the Cometic with stock bolts to 30+psi(guessing around 35), all on pump gas and I've never had a problem. So is it a fluke? Or is because I don't cut corners, I don't have detonation, and I read the instructions?
.

Before that, I had stopped by a performance shop and they wanted to charge me $23 for a container of it. No thanks! I don't use it that often.
)