swapped axle now car shakes while turning

[whe3ls]

so i swapped out a clicking worn passager side axle in my buddys 92 awd auto. we to napa to a new axles for both sides. the axles i pulled out seemed to look slightly shorter than the napa axle.

this is the axle i used
NAPA AUTO PARTS)

should i try tis axle. it is slighly shorter
NAPA AUTO PARTS)

 

[TrevorS]

Your links don't work for me, but I'd suggest measuring the original Vs the replacement and if they are different, make a note of the difference and talk to NAPA. Since the part is now used, return may not be an option, but if there's clearly an error, check it out.