Definitely the 1G BOV. They're reliable as hell. You can put the money you save into other mods.
For 18-20psi, I wouldn't do the Dodge Garage Mod, or if you DO the mod, don't crush the valve because it may make it too stuff and cause the valve to flutter when chopping the throttle at low boost.
My buddy's 2G is running a crushed, Dodge Garage-modded 1G BOV and he's running 22-25psi. If he's making low boost in traffic, the valve will flutter.
Here's how you can mod the base of the 1G BOV to fit your Greddy flange:
Punishment 2G IC pipes, no 1G bov love...