I think black looks the best but its also the worst to have (atleast here in the SW) cause the clear coat starts coming off after a few years.

I'd rate silver #2 in just looks but #1 overall

What?! There are only 4 colors listed, and none of them are the best (my opinion).
The best for me are Kona blue, olso green, Biscayne green, Barcelona red, Durango copper, and the teal that came on 2gb talons.
But if I had to pick from your list, I guess white holds sentimental value because that's what my first one was.

Kona Blue gets my vote too

I loved the Wildberry Metallic on my 96 Talon. Colored really popped! Black is nice as well but shows every flaw which sucks with the sun faded clear coat.

Durango copper and black roof with a mirror polish on it = sex.

Cayenne red with bronze wheels. Also the cream and black leather interior.

Cayenne red is the best in my opinion.

I've owned 5 2g's and 3 of them have been white. White really is the best color. Silver is probably the worst color for a car ever. I wish they wouldnt offer silver, tan and beige for cars at all. Especially sports car. It's just like screaming "BLAND".

I own a Black 98 TSI so I am partial, but one color you didn't list is barcelona red. My son has a 97 Talon that is that color and it is very pretty so I am voting out of the box for barcelona red!

Monarch Green Pearl!

I really like my green. Polo Green Metallic. With a good wax job, it really sparkles in the sun.