pboglio
15+ Year Contributor
- 1,799
- 85
- May 8, 2004
-
Palos Heights,
Illinois
I guess my terminology is not correct. I should say "rarefaction" wave simulation, not acoustical or pulse flow. Time for a new thread, yes.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
This site may earn a commission from merchant
affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
??? I'm confused 2 3 years later the manifold shows up on a all out race car dragster that has always been fast even when it had the Magnus manifold on it proves what? I'm not a fan of the owner or his circle but this car is a FAST dragster. Hell you could probably put a jmf drag manifold on this thing and post the same times and have spent much less.
Wow slipi, come on man. Is this personal? Even if a motor is making crap loads of power, I'm sure you could see if a part was binifitial. Who ever built that car would know this. Well any who. I bought this manifold, so we will see on a fresh built motor what it is capable of.
This manifrold from the gate was a good manifold and probably as good if not better than most designs back when it came out but it has never proved to be worth the 1200 price tag that it has. You figure Magnus has come out with its V3 and JMF has its Drag manifold now all of which use the same concept as this manifold to increase flow without losing velocity. None of which cost 1200. If you can get this for a deal hop on it but if not there are better choices that's all. I just want to clear that up this is in no way a bad or crappy manifold just overpriced.
Tapered runners. How do they work? Magnus still hasn't been able to grasp this concept. They still think the plenum's job is to try to increase velocity. Laughable. The plenum is practically constant pressure if it's large enough in volume. The runners are what increase velocity. What happens when you choke down freeway traffic at the last second? You get a massive pile up and loss of velocity.... Compare that to Magnus' design.
Lol I concur, almost anything is better than a magnus intake. There are quite a few basic guidelines to make an intake that doesn't suck.
1. Plenum volume 1.5-2.5 times the displacement
2. the end extends to about 1-.5 times the area of the plenum past the last runner.
3. tapering the cross sectional area down to about 80% at the end is ok.
My biggest complaint is that I feel most of these have runners that are too short for anything but a motor that lives at 8000-12000RPM. But it would be really hard to get a longer runner that is tapered without using a casting.
I can't believe this disscussion is still going on. It's a nice manifold, and knowing how long it takes to make something like this, $1200 isn't a bad price. I think he has fixed a few shortcomings of the other designs, but it is far from perfect. It's a nice compromise that still fits easily.
It's funny tho, none of the opponents of this manifold, have ANYTHING to show for 2 years later. Armchair quarterbacking must be fun for you guys.
Lol I concur, almost anything is better than a magnus intake. There are quite a few basic guidelines to make an intake that doesn't suck.
1. Plenum volume 1.5-2.5 times the displacement
2. the end extends to about 1-.5 times the area of the plenum past the last runner.
3. tapering the cross sectional area down to about 80% at the end is ok.
My biggest complaint is that I feel most of these have runners that are too short for anything but a motor that lives at 8000-12000RPM. But it would be really hard to get a longer runner that is tapered without using a casting.
I can't believe this disscussion is still going on. It's a nice manifold, and knowing how long it takes to make something like this, $1200 isn't a bad price. I think he has fixed a few shortcomings of the other designs, but it is far from perfect. It's a nice compromise that still fits easily.
It's funny tho, none of the opponents of this manifold, have ANYTHING to show for 2 years later. Armchair quarterbacking must be fun for you guys.
I am stunned that you are backing me up on this manifold.
This manifold is just about AS BIG as you can fit in a 2g. It's a bi*** and a half to get this thing on and off, because it utilizes all the space available.
Never said the thing was old just said that it was good then and is good now. Never said anything different all I EVER said was it's not worth $1200. Your computer probably outperforms the newer computers. I would put JMF's drag manifold up against this thing and seeing how this cost almost twice as much that would mean it should almost outperform it 2 fold....it doesn't. One all out drag car that goes fast doesn't justify a manifold. How has it performed on a more real world setup like the OPs? I'm more a fan of the JMF than Magnus but the magus manifold is on a a green 1g that makes over 1000whp so it can't be that bad and cost A LOT less than this manifold.
Remember when talking price it;s all opinon. What you are willing to pay is your business and none of mine. I just don't want a noob with money to think if he or she buys this they will make SOOO much if anything more than the other manifolds on the market across the board because the results have shown it won't
I can't believe this thread is still alive. Worth is subjective! I don't know why people care about how much some one else is willing to spend on a part. A more expensive product doesn't make it better by any means but at the same time you get what you pay for. It's pathetic how cheap some DSM'ers are when it comes to stuff like this. Go look at what it costs for aftermarket parts on different platforms.
First off I'm not a noob with money. Don't start with the insults. I have built my car with my bare hands, taking the time to read and do things the right way. Never half doing anything. If you remember I even fixed a motor you as a veteran messed up. Me haveing money does not make me ignorant to the value of quality and longevity. I own a Magnus race. I could have used it, but when this came up for sale I asked around and was advices by many true VETRANS to buy it. I listened to them. Now as far as one product costing twice the amount as another product and you getting double the performance out of said product....well that is fullish. You would be happy to see an increase of 3-5% per $100. That's being generous. That just does not happen in the real world. Especially when it comes to performance car parts. What I have learned as a NOOB, is that it is not that any given part will ad Hp to your current setup. Yet it allows the Hp or to to be gained more efficiently. A $250 pair of mikes will not make you run any fast than a pair of $50 pro wings. But by it utilizing air cushions and what ever else goes into a pair of shoes that expensive, it makes the run a lot more comfortable for the runner. Making it easier to complete that marathon without as much stress on the body. Where have you ever seen where something that cost twice as much performs twice as well? Ok now again I'm no engineer, but I know I have the basics right. So stop saying its not worth the money.
You are so right. I have said on many occasions that this is the reason no one wants to bother with these cars. Most everything has to be custom made. Some of those guys don't want to be bothered. Someday it is due to the introduction to the US, I don't think so. It's because of the cheapness. My friend has a g35. He had a intake mani for his car and it cost him 4k. It's a wonder why there are fwd Hondas in the 9s and 8s but I see no fwd Dsm. Or at least there are many more. This is because Honda guys will spend money without wimpering about it.
Dude are you talking about. No one said you were a noob you really got that I was calling you a noob from my post really? All I said was I don't want someone who doesn't no better(never hinted or implied that I was saying YOU) from thinking that this manifold was night and day better than the others out there are thus worth the $500 more that it cost for this than most other top notch manifolds. Like it was said by me and others price is subjective and what's too much is the opinion of the buyer/customer. We as dsmers are all potential customers and me as customer doesn't think it's worth the 1200 price tag you as a customer do. Not that serious I don't even know why this is even still going around in circles. I'm not even sure why this is still going around in cicrles. Other people think it's too much too there are people that think it is. The people that have the money that think it is the people that don't won't
As far as your inapropriate engine reference I'm not gonna go there all I'll say is I've been around but I'm not end all be all engine builder and already admited to messing up. You got a great deal to begin with plus money back so bringing up past things like that is out of place in a thread that has nothing to do with engines or even me personally and my experience.
Aslo perfect example with the Mikes because that's how this manifold comes off as a part that because of it's name and the builders repuation as making expensive higher quality stuff they can justify charging a crazy price. I own Mikes and I have other sneakers and my Mikes are NOT my most comfortable now do I jump the highest in them. They just have a little Mike logo on them...so they cost a shit load. Supply and demand mixed with the American need to keep up with the jones's. Btw my Trailblazer SS intake manifold after $500 in machine work just to get the injector bungs drilled out $500 for manifold and $200 for the elbow to bolt up to the tb cost yes that's right $1200 so it's not a matter of being cheap it's a matter of worth which again is determined by the buyer.
Cheap cheap said the little bird. $500, a mass produced intake for a sbc is still 250. And you expect.this for 500.get lost.
I agree 500 is lowballing but I agree in principal but not in practice. Its not about what else you could buy with 1200 its that THIS manifold is overpriced at 1200...in my opinion. Just cause something is rare doesnt automatically make it valuable And vise versa things that are a dime a dozen arent always cheap. Even with that said I could see this manifood at 8 maybe 900 max because it is good and rare. Going with a jmf or Magnus will not keep you from achieving your goal.